English
日本語
한국어
简体中文
繁體中文
Italiano
español
Deutsch
Русский
An interesting aspect arises when we look at how "ought to" is used in English. "Ought to" is applied in three cases:
- Duty
- Recommendation
- Expectation
1) Duty
In English, we say:
"You ought to apologize."
(謝るべきだ。)
In German, we use "sollte":
"Du solltest dich entschuldigen."
2) Recommendation
For recommendations, we also use "sollte" in both English and German.
Example:
"You ought to eat healthier."
"Du solltest gesünder essen."
3) Expectation
When expressing an expectation, we can use the same structure in English, but might have to change in German:
- English:
"It ought to be over by now." - Japanese:
今終わるはずだ。 - German:
In German, as in Japanese, we need to switch the grammar:
"Es müsste jetzt zu Ende sein."
While we can still use "sollte" in German, there is a difference in nuance between "müsste" and "sollte."
- Müsste indicates an expectation based on evidence or logic.
- Sollte, on the other hand, is based on a general expectation, but there is more uncertainty.
Examples:
-
Müsste (based on evidence):
The movie is scheduled to end at 16:30. If someone asks at the theater, "Is the movie already over?" and you know the schedule, you would say in German:
"Sie können bereits reingehen. Der Film müsste schon um 16:20 Uhr zu Ende gegangen sein."
(This implies that, based on the schedule, the movie is very likely over.) -
Sollte (general expectation with some uncertainty):
"Das Meeting sollte um 14 Uhr enden."
(The meeting was scheduled to end at 2 PM, but there is a possibility that it has been extended.)
Comments (0)