Grammar: Responding to Negative Questions in English

Cecily G.

Dear English learners,

When responding to positive questions, students aren't usually confused (although some may confuse which verb to use):

A: Are you going to work tomorrow?
B: Yes, I am.
     or
    No, I am not. 

A: Do you have an umbrella?
    Yes, I do.
    or
    No, I do not.

A: Have you heard the news?
B: Yes, I have.
     or 
    No, I haven't. 

In positive questions, if you agree with the question you say 'yes', and if you disagree, you say 'no'. 

However, when responding to negative questions there can be more confusion:

A: Aren't you going to work tomorrow?
B: No, I'm not.

or

A: You're not going to work tomorrow?
B: No, I'm not.

If you agree with a negative question, you have to answer no. Some of my students say this is not natural for them. (They want to answer yes). 

If you disagree with a negative question, you have to answer yes:

A: You aren't going to work tomorrow?
B: Yes, I am going to work. 

A: You don't have an umbrella?
B: Yes, I do.

Note that if you're disagreeing with the negative question, you might put more emphasis on the verb to stress it. 

If you're agreeing with the negative question, you can also omit the verb and people commonly do in spoken English:

A: You aren't tired?
B: No (I'm not). 

The rest of the sentence will be assumed. 

Feel free to write your own negative questions and answers in the comments. 





專欄文章僅為講師個人觀點,不代表 Cafetalk 立場。

回應 (0)

登入之後,添加評論 登入 »
Premium ribbon

來自:

住在:

授課種類

講師會的語言

英語   母語程度
法語   精通
日語   只能說一點
義大利語   只能說一點
德語   只能說一點
中文   只能說一點

Cecily G. 講師的人氣專欄

  • On Tuesday or In Tuesday?

    The other day my student said "See you in Tues". Maybe you know it should be "See you on Tues". I r...

    Cecily G.

    Cecily G.

    0
    8131
    2022 年 5 月 3 日
  • Think Small to Accomplish Big Things - Michael Phelps talk

    What small things are you going to do to accomplish big things? What small things can you do today,...

    Cecily G.

    Cecily G.

    0
    7383
    2021 年 9 月 10 日
  • Festival of Lessons and Carols

    Dear students and other Cafetalk readers,I'm listening to a recording of the Christmas service call...

    Cecily G.

    Cecily G.

    0
    6948
    2021 年 12 月 25 日
  • Travel Vocabulary

    Hi students,Today I was having a lesson with one of my students and we started talking about travel...

    Cecily G.

    Cecily G.

    0
    6050
    2022 年 2 月 26 日
« 講師專欄首頁
線上客服諮詢