Grammar: Responding to Negative Questions in English

Cecily G.

Dear English learners,

When responding to positive questions, students aren't usually confused (although some may confuse which verb to use):

A: Are you going to work tomorrow?
B: Yes, I am.
     or
    No, I am not. 

A: Do you have an umbrella?
    Yes, I do.
    or
    No, I do not.

A: Have you heard the news?
B: Yes, I have.
     or 
    No, I haven't. 

In positive questions, if you agree with the question you say 'yes', and if you disagree, you say 'no'. 

However, when responding to negative questions there can be more confusion:

A: Aren't you going to work tomorrow?
B: No, I'm not.

or

A: You're not going to work tomorrow?
B: No, I'm not.

If you agree with a negative question, you have to answer no. Some of my students say this is not natural for them. (They want to answer yes). 

If you disagree with a negative question, you have to answer yes:

A: You aren't going to work tomorrow?
B: Yes, I am going to work. 

A: You don't have an umbrella?
B: Yes, I do.

Note that if you're disagreeing with the negative question, you might put more emphasis on the verb to stress it. 

If you're agreeing with the negative question, you can also omit the verb and people commonly do in spoken English:

A: You aren't tired?
B: No (I'm not). 

The rest of the sentence will be assumed. 

Feel free to write your own negative questions and answers in the comments. 





저장 목록에 추가됨

이 칼럼은 강사가 게시한 글로서 강사의 주관적인 의견이며 카페토크의 공식 입장이 아닙니다.

응답 (0)

로그인하여 코멘트 등록 로그인 »
Premium ribbon

from:

in:

레슨 카테고리

강사가 사용하는 언어

영어    모국어
프랑스어    불편하지않음
일본어    단어약간
이탈리아어    단어약간
독일어    단어약간
중국어    단어약간

Cecily G.강사의 인기 칼럼

  • A Bird in the Hand is Worth Two in the Bush

    I have been thinking recently about the proverb: "a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush". It...

    Cecily G.

    Cecily G.

    0
    5849
    2015년 8월 17일
  • On Tuesday or In Tuesday?

    The other day my student said "See you in Tues". Maybe you know it should be "See you on Tues". I r...

    Cecily G.

    Cecily G.

    0
    5610
    2022년 5월 03일
  • idiom: "to cost an arm and a leg"

    English idioms sound strange sometimes! There is an idiom "to cost an arm and a leg". It means some...

    Cecily G.

    Cecily G.

    0
    5408
    2015년 8월 25일
  • Social Distancing

    Hello English learners,Today I wanted to introduce the term social distancing. Have you heard it?It...

    Cecily G.

    Cecily G.

    0
    5309
    2020년 3월 30일
« 강사 칼럼으로 돌아가기
부담없이 질문해 주세요!